Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • MY ACCOUNTToggle My Account Menu
    Forgot Password?

    Don't have an account? Sign up now

  • 125 N. York Street
    Elmhurst, IL 60126
    (630) 832-8800
    See Store Hours
Cottage Hill Diamonds

  • Click Here to Apply Now

    Financing
  • Engagement Rings

    Choose the style of ring your are looking for below.

    Classic Halo Promise
    Modern Solitare Custom Design
    Vintage 3-Stone Women's Wedding Bands
  • Diamonds
    • 2ct Diamond Solitaire
    • 3ct Diamond Solitaire
    • Loose Diamond Inventory
    • Antwerp Diamonds
    • Diamond Studs
    • Diamond Trade Up Policy
    • Fire & Ice Diamonds
    • How We Buy Diamonds
    • What are Lab Grown Diamonds?
    • Why Buy a Ring or Diamond From Us?
  • Designers

    Our Designer Collections.

    Citizen Eco Drive Colored Stone Jewelry Crown Ring Gili B Imperial Pearls Noam Carver Atelier
    Kirk Kara Makur Mark Schneider Noam Carver Rembrandt Charms
    Sylvie Tracy Arrington Studios Verragio William Henry Studio Custom Jewelry
  • Jewelry
    Engagement Rings
    3-StoneClassicHaloModernSolitaireVintagePromiseWomen's Wedding Bands
    Bracelets and Bangles
    Colored Stone BraceletsFlex Bangles
    Earrings
    Diamond EarringsColored Stone Earrings
    Rings
    Colored Stone RingsWedding BandsAnniversary BandsSemi-mount Engagement RingsWhite Gold Wedding BandsSolitaire Engagement RingsHalo Engagement RingsMen's Diamond Wedding BandsPave Engagement RingsThree Stone Engagement RingsVintage Engagement RingsWomen's Diamond Engagement Rings
    Men's Jewelry
    Men's Wedding Bands
    Pendants & Necklaces
    Diamond Pendants and NecklacesColored Stone Pendants & Necklaces
    Watches
    Charms
    Charm Necklaces
    Wedding Jewelry
    Money ClipsRing Enhancers
    Silver JewelryCharm BraceletsKnivesPens
    Pearl Jewelry
    Pearl BraceletsPearl SetsPearl PinsPearl RingsPearl PendantsPearl EarringsPearl Necklaces
    Custom Jewelry
    Jewelry
  • Services
    • Appraisals
    • Buying and Selling Gold
    • Custom Jewelry
    • Financing
    • Jewelry Repairs
    • Watch Repair and Restoration
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Blog
    • COVID Safety
    • Create a Wishlist
    • Customer Reviews
    • Fire & Ice Diamonds
    • Military Discount
    • Privacy Policy
    • Return Policy
    • Engagement Ring Contest Details
    • Wedding Band Event
  • Education
  • Contact
  1. Jewelry
  2. Rings
  3. Vintage Engagement Rings

Vintage Engagement Rings

Filtering by: CLEAR ALL
Vintage Engagement Rings
  • Anniversary Bands
  • Colored Stone Rings
  • Halo Engagement Rings
  • Pave Engagement Rings
  • Solitaire Engagement Rings
  • Three Stone Engagement Rings
  • Vintage Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
  • White Gold Wedding Bands
  • Women's Diamond Engagement Rings
View     
  • Previous
  • Next
  • 1(current)
  • 2
  • 3
  • All
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pear-Platinum Pear
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003r-Platinum Round
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003ov-Platinum Oval
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring features pave' set round brilliant-cut diamonds in a beautiful vint...

Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pr-Platinum Princess
$4,950.00
As low as: $412.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features a pave' set diamond twisted ...

Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pear-18k Rose Gold Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pear-18k Yellow Gold Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003ov-18k Yellow Gold Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring features pave' set round brilliant-cut diamonds in a beautiful vint...

Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pear-18k Two Tone Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003r-18k Two Tone Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003r-18k Yellow Gold Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003r-18k White Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003r-18k Rose Gold Round
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pear-18k White Pear
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003ov-18k White Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring features pave' set round brilliant-cut diamonds in a beautiful vint...

Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003ov-18k Two Tone Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring features pave' set round brilliant-cut diamonds in a beautiful vint...

Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003ov-18k Rose Gold Oval
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring features pave' set round brilliant-cut diamonds in a beautiful vint...

Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pr-18k Yellow Gold Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features a pave' set diamond twisted ...

Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pr-18k White Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features a pave' set diamond twisted ...

Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pr-18k Two Tone Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features a pave' set diamond twisted ...

Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pr-18k Rose Gold Princess
$4,550.00
As low as: $379.17 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features a pave' set diamond twisted ...

Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pear-14k Two Tone Pear
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003pear-14k Rose Gold Pear
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring from the Venetian Collection, features round brilliant-cut diamonds...

Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003ov-14k Two Tone Oval
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring features pave' set round brilliant-cut diamonds in a beautiful vint...

Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days
Venetian-5003ov-14k Rose Gold Oval
$4,350.00
As low as: $362.50 for 12 months
Ships in 7-10 Business Days

VENETIAN-5003 engagement ring features pave' set round brilliant-cut diamonds in a beautiful vint...

  • Previous
  • Next
  • 1(current)
  • 2
  • 3
  • All
Services
  • Jewelry Repairs
  • Watch Repair & Restoration
  • Buying & Selling Gold
  • Insurance
  • Financing
Follow Us
Categories
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Jewelry
  • Bracelets
  • Charms
  • Earrings
  • Men's Jewelry
  • Pendants & Necklaces
Engagement Rings
  • Custom Design
  • Kirk Kara
  • Mark Schneider
  • Noam Carver
  • Sylvie
  • Verragio
Fashion Jewelry
  • Colored Stone Jewelry
  • Gili B
  • Makur
  • Rembrandt Charms
  • Tracy Arrington Studios
  • William Henry
125 N. York Street
, Elmhurst, IL 60126
(630) 832-8800
Follow Us

© 2025 Cottage Hill Diamonds. All Rights Reserved. Website designed, maintained, and hosted by Punchmark. Accessibility Statement.

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.
Our Store Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday - Wednesday: 10:00 am - 5:30 pm
Thursday: 10:00 am - 7:00 pm
Friday - Saturday: 10:00 am - 5:00 pm
Sunday: Closed