Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • MY ACCOUNTToggle My Account Menu
  • 125 N. York Street
    Elmhurst, IL 60126
    (630) 832-8800
    See Store Hours
Cottage Hill Diamonds
  • Click Here to Apply Now

    Financing
  • Engagement Rings

    Choose the style of ring your are looking for below.

    Classic Halo Promise
    Modern Solitare Custom Design
    Vintage 3-Stone Women's Wedding Bands
  • Diamonds
    • 2ct Diamond Solitaire
    • 3ct Diamond Solitaire
    • Loose Diamond Inventory
    • Antwerp Diamonds
    • Diamond Studs
    • Diamond Trade Up Policy
    • Fire & Ice Diamonds
    • How We Buy Diamonds
    • What are Lab Grown Diamonds?
    • Why Buy a Ring or Diamond From Us?
  • Designers

    Our Designer Collections.

    Citizen Eco Drive Colored Stone Jewelry Crown Ring Gili B Imperial Pearls Noam Carver Atelier
    Kirk Kara Makur Mark Schneider Noam Carver Rembrandt Charms
    Sylvie Tracy Arrington Studios Verragio William Henry Studio Custom Jewelry
  • Jewelry
    Engagement Rings
    3-StoneClassicHaloModernSolitaireVintagePromiseWomen's Wedding Bands
    Bracelets and Bangles
    Colored Stone BraceletsFlex Bangles
    Earrings
    Diamond EarringsColored Stone Earrings
    Rings
    Colored Stone RingsWedding BandsAnniversary BandsSemi-mount Engagement RingsWhite Gold Wedding BandsSolitaire Engagement RingsHalo Engagement RingsMen's Diamond Wedding BandsPave Engagement RingsThree Stone Engagement RingsVintage Engagement RingsWomen's Diamond Engagement Rings
    Men's Jewelry
    Men's Wedding Bands
    Pendants & Necklaces
    Diamond Pendants and NecklacesColored Stone Pendants & Necklaces
    Watches
    Charms
    Charm Necklaces
    Wedding Jewelry
    Money ClipsRing Enhancers
    Silver JewelryCharm BraceletsKnivesPens
    Pearl Jewelry
    Pearl BraceletsPearl SetsPearl PinsPearl RingsPearl PendantsPearl EarringsPearl Necklaces
    Custom Jewelry

    Jewelry
  • Services
    • Appraisals
    • Buying and Selling Gold
    • Custom Jewelry
    • Financing
    • Jewelry Repairs
    • Watch Repair and Restoration
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Blog
    • COVID Safety
    • Create a Wishlist
    • Customer Reviews
    • Fire & Ice Diamonds
    • Military Discount
    • Privacy Policy
    • Return Policy
    • Engagement Ring Contest Details
    • Wedding Band Event
  • Education
  • Contact
  1. Jewelry
  2. Blog
  3. Jewelry
  4. Anniversary Gift Ideas: How to Find the Right Piece of Jewelry
Jewelry

Anniversary Gift Ideas: How to Find the Right Piece of Jewelry

Published: Sep 23, 2024
Anniversary Gift Ideas: How to Find the Right Piece of Jewelry
Author: 
Jordan Hill

Anniversaries are a special time to celebrate the love you share with your partner. Whether you're commemorating your first year together or your 50th, finding the perfect gift can be a challenge. Jewelry is a timeless option that holds sentimental value and can be the perfect way to show your partner how much you care. We’ve gathered some tips to help you pick the perfect piece of anniversary jewelry in the greater Chicago area.  
 

Consider Your Partner's Style 

The first step in choosing the right piece of jewelry is to consider your partner’s personal style. Do they prefer classic or modern designs? Are they drawn to minimalist pieces, or do they love bold, statement jewelry? Think about the types of jewelry they already wear — whether it’s dainty earrings, stackable rings, or sparkling necklaces. 
 
Taking note of your partner’s preferences will help you narrow down your options. For example, if they love understated grace, a pair of delicate diamond drop earrings or a timeless diamond pendant necklace might be the perfect choice. On the other hand, if they prefer a bolder look, a striking diamond bangle bracelet or a custom-designed ring could be a great option. 
 

Pay Attention to Milestone Anniversaries

Many couples choose to follow traditional anniversary gift guidelines, which often suggest specific types of jewelry for each milestone. While these suggestions can provide helpful inspiration, it’s important to personalize the gift based on your relationship. Here are a few milestone anniversaries and corresponding jewelry ideas: 
 

  • 1st Anniversary (Gold) 
    A pendant or necklace is a great way to mark your first year together. 
  • 5th Anniversary (Sapphire) 
    A ring or a pair of earrings can beautifully represent five years of love. 
  • 10th Anniversary (Diamond) 
    A diamond anniversary band or a pair of diamond earrings is a classic and meaningful way to celebrate a decade together. 
  • 20th Anniversary (Emerald) 
    Emerald jewelry is the traditional gift for 20 years of marriage, symbolizing the growth and depth of your relationship. 
  • 30th Anniversary (Pearl) 
    Pearl jewelry, whether a necklace or earrings, is a classy choice for a 30th anniversary. 


While these traditional milestones offer a guideline, don’t feel constrained by them. The most important thing is to choose a piece that reflects your love and the unique journey you’ve shared. 
 
Upgrade a Wedding Band 
Another thoughtful way to mark a significant anniversary is by upgrading your partner’s wedding band. Perhaps when you first exchanged vows, you opted for a simpler band. Now, as you celebrate the years you’ve spent together, upgrading to a more intricate or custom-designed band can be a powerful symbol of how your relationship has grown. 
 
At Cottage Hill Diamonds, we carry stunning designs from Verragio, known for their intricate, luxurious wedding bands. Upgrading your partner’s band to a Verragio is a way to honor the years you’ve shared and look forward to years ahead. Whether it’s adding diamonds to the band or choosing a more ornate design, this upgrade can be a meaningful and stylish gesture. 
 
Some Gift Ideas Available at Cottage Hill Diamonds 
If you're looking for specific pieces of jewelry that can make your anniversary even more memorable, here are a few standout options from Cottage Hill Diamonds: 
 

  • Anniversary Bands: Celebrate your journey together with a stunning anniversary band. Our selection of anniversary bands offers a variety of styles, from simple sophistication to diamond-encrusted designs. 
  • Earrings: For a timeless gift, consider a pair of elegant earrings. These London Blue Topaz and Diamond Drop Earrings are a beautiful choice, or you can opt for classic diamond hoop earrings to elevate her formalwear. 
  • Bracelets: A diamond bracelet is a sophisticated choice for an anniversary gift. Our selection includes pieces like this diamond bangle bracelet and this  freshwater pearl bracelet. 
  • Pendant Necklace: This diamond pendant or this sapphire & diamond pendant make an intimate, personal gift. It’s a piece your partner can wear every day as a reminder of your love. 

 

Create a Custom Piece at Cottage Hill Diamonds 

For a truly unique and personal gift, consider creating a custom piece of jewelry at Cottage Hill Diamonds. Designing a custom piece allows you to craft something that no one else is wearing — a one-of-a-kind item that reflects your love story and personal style. 
 
Whether you want to incorporate specific gemstones, engravings, or design elements, our team can help you bring your vision to life. Browse our custom jewelry portfolio for inspiration from past designs we’ve created for customers, and let us help you make your anniversary gift truly unforgettable. 
 

Let Us Help You Find the Perfect Gift to Make Your Anniversary Sparkle 

Your anniversary is a special time to reflect on the love and commitment you've shared, and the right piece of jewelry can make the celebration even more meaningful. Whether you're choosing a classic pair of earrings, upgrading a wedding band, or designing a custom piece,  
 
Cottage Hill Diamonds is here to help you find the perfect gift that symbolizes your unique relationship. Stop by our shop in Elmhurst so we can guide you to the jewelry that will make your partner feel cherished on this special occasion.

Categories
DiamondsEngagement Rings3Gift Giving3About UsJewelry13
  • Previous Article
  • Next Article
Services
  • Jewelry Repairs
  • Watch Repair & Restoration
  • Buying & Selling Gold
  • Insurance
  • Financing
Follow Us
Categories
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Jewelry
  • Bracelets
  • Charms
  • Earrings
  • Men's Jewelry
  • Pendants & Necklaces
Engagement Rings
  • Custom Design
  • Kirk Kara
  • Mark Schneider
  • Noam Carver
  • Sylvie
  • Verragio
Fashion Jewelry
  • Colored Stone Jewelry
  • Gili B
  • Makur
  • Rembrandt Charms
  • Tracy Arrington Studios
  • William Henry
125 N. York Street
, Elmhurst, IL 60126
(630) 832-8800
Follow Us

© 2025 Cottage Hill Diamonds. All Rights Reserved. Website designed, maintained, and hosted by Punchmark. Accessibility Statement.

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.