125 N. York Street
Elmhurst, IL 60126
(630) 832-8800

Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

MaryPat and Jim


We had a wonderful experience with Cottage Hill Diamonds, Collin’s attention to detail was exceptional. Our time spent working with Collin on the design was delightful and pressure free. Collin along with Mark Schneider’s staff helped us with every step of the design of our ring, the result was an anniversary ring that exceeded our expectations. We have a family run business background and we enjoyed working with another family run business. . We highly recommend working with Collin and the Family at Cottage Hill.

Bonnie Wallick


Colin took care of my sister and I. We had some questions on some jewelry.He spent quality time with us we never felt rushed he answered all our questions. We never felt we had to buy anything he was just there to help. I did get two rings re-sized and cleaned and was very happy with the service I would tell anyone that I had a excellent experience.

Current Rating on Google+: 4.9 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Paul Luczak

April 23, 2018

Abby and I had a phenomenal experience buying our engagement ring with Sam's help at Cottage Hill Diamonds. Sam was able to find exactly what Abby was looking for, and on follow up visits took the time to walk me through all the critical diamond characteristics and pricing options. She made a concerted effort to eliminate stress but also made sure we had all the information we needed. I would definitely recommend Sam and Cottage Hill to any soon to be engaged couples in the Chicagoland area.

Cesar Diaz

March 16, 2018

Hello fellow diamond and jewelry buyers. Do not...I repeat...do not be skeptic of the 5 star reviews for Cottage Hill Diamonds. You will not get the world class service and experience from any other jeweler. Do you know how it feels, to walk into a jewelry store and feel like you're being look down upon? Like, they just know you're not there to buy and could care less to show you anything? I Do. You WILL NOT get that bad feeling with Cottage Hill. I was lucky enough to get Drew as my salesman but I could see the same amount of professionalism being given to every other customer in the store. Don't waste your time anywhere else, Cottage Hill has loose diamonds, house brand and name brand jewelry. I am a customer for life. Thank You Drew and the Team at Cottage Hill Diamonds, Cesar

Emily Mueller

February 24, 2018

Great service and a fair price! Had a custom piece done here and it turned out amazing! We came with a family heirloom ring setting and worked with Marisa to get it cleaned and put an aquamarine stone into it. With her help we were able to get it done before I left for a trip. Highly recommend.


March 28, 2018

My wife and I were recently trying to find a jeweler who could match a lost diamond earring and in our search stumbled upon Cottage Hill Diamonds. It was clear the minute we walked in the door that this was the place. Drew and Marisa were incredibly knowledgeable, patient with our questions, and offered us many options. They didn't just try to sell us any diamond they had on hand. They worked hard to find one that matched the remaining earring and that was within our budget. We drove 60 miles from SE Wisconsin to get to Cottage Hill and are extremely pleased with the service we received. Highly recommended.

John Stumpf

February 22, 2018

My wife and I have been purchasing jewelry from Cottage Hills Diamonds for years and been very satisfied with their service. Last spring I wanted to but yellow sapphires for ear ring studs for Barbara. Collin Hill got the book of stones and she selected some and had them mounted. Before Christmas I decided to get similar stones for a necklace. So Collin got a book and she selected what she wanted, also picking a mounting and gold chain. If you do not see what you want they can order what is needed. While she shops I enjoy the coffee, candy and cookies.