125 N. York Street
Elmhurst, IL 60126
(630) 832-8800

Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

MaryPat and Jim


We had a wonderful experience with Cottage Hill Diamonds, Collin’s attention to detail was exceptional. Our time spent working with Collin on the design was delightful and pressure free. Collin along with Mark Schneider’s staff helped us with every step of the design of our ring, the result was an anniversary ring that exceeded our expectations. We have a family run business background and we enjoyed working with another family run business. . We highly recommend working with Collin and the Family at Cottage Hill.

Bonnie Wallick


Colin took care of my sister and I. We had some questions on some jewelry.He spent quality time with us we never felt rushed he answered all our questions. We never felt we had to buy anything he was just there to help. I did get two rings re-sized and cleaned and was very happy with the service I would tell anyone that I had a excellent experience.

Current Rating on Google+: 4.9 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

John Prestianni

May 17, 2018

I had the pleasure of dealing with Collin, He was super friendly right from the beginning and this was the first place I went to for engagement ring shopping off the recommendation of a friend. I felt that he genuinely cared and he made this whole process so easy I didn't even bother looking elsewhere. Everyone in the store is very nice as well. Collin answered all of my questions and I never felt like i didn't understand something, and If i was confused he would re-explain it or we would follow up in emails. This is the first review I'm leaving, and I highly recommend you try this place first for engagement rings if you want an excellent overall experience.

Aaron Dunbar

April 25, 2018

Marisa and Collin are the best!!! We were new to Elmhurst and had been shopping around for the engagement and wedding rings when decided to take a gander at Cottage Hill Diamonds and see if the hype was true. Absolutely zero (Kelvin, that is) doubt. The ambience and the love we felt the second we walked in was enough to reignite the excitement and introduce the fun in the search of rings for both myself and my wife (the complimentary beer and wine helped, too!). Marisa took my wife's hand and gave her the "Be Our Guest" experience and helped her find the perfect diamonds and designs within our price range. No coercion, no gimmicks, no BS. The diamonds are lab-grown which, after a little in-store research, were vastly more appealing than traditional diamonds. After all decisions were made, they managed to get the order in and have the custom-made rings completed in the super short window we requested! The experience was immensely more enjoyable than I had anticipated and the team excelled far beyond any expectations. I've never written a 5-star review more deserving. To top it off, they even sent us a thank you gift card! We certainly will be returning for many more future purchases. Thank you again, Marisa and Collin!

Warren Ali

April 28, 2018

Marisa is awesome! She has worked with me and my wife over the past few years and this time she found the perfect bracelet for me. Her diligent research found the bracelet I wanted based on a description I gave to her. She gently keep me in mind while I made a job transition which delayed the purchase. She has a great eye for style and value! Fantastic working with her and the team at Cottage Hill!

Alicia Torimoto

June 16, 2018

Great customer service and quick too! I needed to get my engagement ring resized and bought my wedding band from here. Both were done ahead of schedule! I worked with Marisa through the entire process and she was fabulous. They had a great selection of rings. I highly recommend this store!

Jim Elste

June 15, 2018

My experience buying an engagement ring with cottage hill was really great. Colin was knowledgeable, friendly, and very respectful of my budget. He was able to answer all of my questions and was very patient with me as I considered the purchase over several weeks. I will be recommending them to family and friends.