125 N. York Street
Elmhurst, IL 60126
(630) 832-8800

Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

MaryPat and Jim


We had a wonderful experience with Cottage Hill Diamonds, Collin’s attention to detail was exceptional. Our time spent working with Collin on the design was delightful and pressure free. Collin along with Mark Schneider’s staff helped us with every step of the design of our ring, the result was an anniversary ring that exceeded our expectations. We have a family run business background and we enjoyed working with another family run business. . We highly recommend working with Collin and the Family at Cottage Hill.

Bonnie Wallick


Colin took care of my sister and I. We had some questions on some jewelry.He spent quality time with us we never felt rushed he answered all our questions. We never felt we had to buy anything he was just there to help. I did get two rings re-sized and cleaned and was very happy with the service I would tell anyone that I had a excellent experience.

Current Rating on Google+: 4.9 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Sufy Seedat

November 5, 2017

My fiance found this place and we decided to go there for the engagement ring. We connected with drew and he was extremely helpful and very knowledgable and very accomodating. He explained everything in detail and very patiently and provided the best customer service I could ask for. I am a very indecisive person, but Drew was very patient with me and answered all my questions to make sure I was confident in my purchase. He worked with my price point and was cognizant not to show me/us anything that was way over my price range. All in all, I would highly recommend Cottage Hill as well as Drew. He is extremely genuine and knowledgeable and patient. I am very confident and at ease with my purchase. Thank you Cottage Hill and Drew! Great customer service!

Kathryn Garelli

September 15, 2017

My experience was amazing. Drew patiently helped us with a renewal ring. We had been married for 28 years and needed something to launch us into the final trimester of our life, and heal some hardships along the way. My new ring is a daily reminder of what we have accomplished, the gift that our unity has given our children, and a reinforcement of the commitment in the years to come. In a society of technology where interactions come and go, get deleted, this ring is a lasting endorsement of the love we share and the sacrifices we made to get here. I plan to use Cottage Hill for all future occasions because the intimate atmosphere and personal service is a lost art and therefore, so important in today's times. Thank you Drew and the whole team, Diane Garelli.

Timothy Vandenburgh

November 20, 2017

Drew did an amazing job helping me find the perfect ring! My favorite thing was he never up-sold me, just just fit my budget!

Anne N

August 24, 2017

I was originally a bit unsure of this store because it didn't have too many reviews when I first checked it out on sites like yelp and the Knot, but I ended up deciding to go in because it was one of the few stores in the area that sells lab created diamonds (100% conflict-free, is a real diamond, and avoids the De Beers diamond monopoly). I was really happy with the level of service we received. We were helped by Marisa, who was great about answering all my questions. I didn't feel rushed at all, and the ring came out looking gorgeous. We were allowed to look at the diamonds in different types of lighting, and received the ring right on time. I definitely recommend Cottage Hill Diamonds!

Nancy O'Brien

August 17, 2017

Decided to take my engagement ring in for a long overdue "check up" and I was so glad I did! One of the stones was loose. I escaped a tragedy that would have been awful. Marissa was so great, that I decided to ask her about a set of earrings that I needed reset; she helped with that right away. Two wonderful visits and I am now a big fan. I'll be back soon!