125 N. York Street
Elmhurst, IL 60126
(630) 832-8800

Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

MaryPat and Jim


We had a wonderful experience with Cottage Hill Diamonds, Collin’s attention to detail was exceptional. Our time spent working with Collin on the design was delightful and pressure free. Collin along with Mark Schneider’s staff helped us with every step of the design of our ring, the result was an anniversary ring that exceeded our expectations. We have a family run business background and we enjoyed working with another family run business. . We highly recommend working with Collin and the Family at Cottage Hill.

Bonnie Wallick


Colin took care of my sister and I. We had some questions on some jewelry.He spent quality time with us we never felt rushed he answered all our questions. We never felt we had to buy anything he was just there to help. I did get two rings re-sized and cleaned and was very happy with the service I would tell anyone that I had a excellent experience.

Current Rating in Google: 4.9 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

deidre waltz

June 29, 2018

Cottage Hill Diamonds is an amazing jeweler! They were able to design the perfect piece for me and well within budget! I had an original price in mind, but then my budget took a hit - emergency vet bills! Marisa was able to find me the perfect stone within my much reduced budget. It’s not the stone I originally wanted, but she actually found a similar stone that is just as gorgeous! When I went in to pick it up, I brought my now healthy dog with me. The entire staff welcomed her into the store and gave her lots of love! As my dog and budget heal, I will save up enough money for my next treasure! I highly recommend Cottage Hill! Thank you Marisa!!

Joe Kovachevich

September 28, 2018

Cottage Hill took excellent care of me. Fixed my watch up in no time and got it back to me for a super fair price. This is definitely my new spot for all my future watch repairs. These guys rock

Monica Taylor

August 16, 2018

Cottage Hill Diamonds is ABSOLUTELY amazing! From the moment I picked out engagement rings until the moment I received mine. Marisa was with me for an hour and a half AT LEAST while I picked out rings that I potentially would receive. After I got proposed to my ring had to be looked at and taken in to fix one of the loose diamonds and Marisa made sure I got my ring back that same day!!! If I had to do it all over again I would pick the same place and Marisa again! So grateful!!

Grant Wiersum

October 6, 2018

Drew was awesome and guided me through an extensive repair to a 100+ year-old piece. I never felt pressured or like I wasn't the one making the decisions. He was an excellent resource in guiding me through the process and we couldn't be happier with the result.

Jake Kreutzer

August 20, 2018

I went to so many places looking for an engagement ring. Everyplace I went they were unwilling to work with my budget and didn't have what I was looking for. Then I went to Cottage Hill Diamonds; I walked in and was immediately helped! They were able to show me diamonds and bands that were within my budget and blew me away with the quality! I definitely recommend Cottage Hill Diamonds to anyone who is looking for a place where they will not only work with you but will teach you a thing or two about engagement rings!

Current Rating on Yelp: 4.5 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Monica T.


Cottage Hill Diamonds is ABSOLUTELY amazing! From the moment I picked out engagement rings until the moment I received mine. Marisa was with me for an hour...READ MORE

Joe K.


Cottage Hill took excellent care of me. They fixed my watch up for me and got it back to me in no time. Definitely my new place for all my future watch...READ MORE

Paul L.


Abby and I had a phenomenal experience buying our engagement ring with Sam's help at Cottage Hill Diamonds! As a first time jewelry buyer I was not sure...READ MORE